| 
View
 

IBPSA NY chapter review of simulation tools

Page history last edited by Brian Matthews 12 years, 10 months ago

 

Below is a chart summarizing building simulation software from the perspective of software users.

As this information is very subjective, it is dependent on:

  1. Ease of frustration by the operator/online resume writer /user.
  2. Number of people contributing to this chart ephedra.
    • number of people who have edited this writing service chart :  1  (low to non-existent accuracy). 
    • As the number of people reviewing this weight loss diet. chart increases, so to will it's accuracy improve (hopefully). ipad case
Key:   
Unknown =blank  
High HI
Medium  M
Low  L
Easy E
Partially P
Hard  HA
Yes Y
No N
Not Applicable NA
Approximately  AP

 

  Equest 3.63 Equest 3.1e(refrigeration) Energy Plus Design Builder (energy plus) Design Builder/CFD PLUG (only cfd) TRACE COOL TOOL 
Adequate information available? Y P Y Y   Y  
Number of users HI L M L L HI L
Software matches current practices and designs?  P P Y P      
Number of projects for a user to become qualified +8 +8 +10 +10 +10   +10
Learning time (weeks) 2-5 6 10 2-4 5   +6
Baseline model creation for novice (days) 4-8 +18 +14 6-8 4-8    
Model creation for expert (days) 2-3 4-8 2-3 3-4 3-4   10-20
Finding Errors  M HA HA HA      
Troubleshooting  ease E HA HA HA      
HVAC representation and options M L HI HI   L  
Simulates Tall Rooms well?  N NA Y AP Y N  
Input obvious? Y P P P   Y Y
Output detailed & clear enough to troubleshoot? Y N P P      
Refrigeration cabinets? Y Y Y     N Y
Refrigerated Warehouses? Medium Temperature   Y       N Y
Refrigerated Warehouses? -10 Low Temperature simulation N P Y     N Y
CFD, FEA?         Y N  
Degree of complex solar reflection? AP   Y Y Y    
Can simulate CHP?   N Y Y   N  
Can simulate Solar panels on roof? Y N Y Y   N  
Can simulate non-coincident WLHP systems? Y NA   Y   N  
Can simulate Geothermal? AP N Y Y   N  
Acceptable to LEED 2.2 Y            
Acceptable to NYSERDA Y            
Acceptable to MPP program              

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.